I think such cases need to be studied, case by case, in military courts. In most cases, I am sure, the accused will be let free, and in such cases they deserve some kind of official recognition, not a medal, but a kind of letter of appreciation or something. In some cases, however, there will be abuse, and these should be prosecuted.
There will be abuse. Every army has some. Marines are professionals and would not usually abuse the rules. However, there are and always will be exceptions. There is a good reason judicial system exists, isn't there? I cannot vouchsafe for its 100% accuracy in making decisions, but neither can one when seaking for the marines in a battle.
As for this particular case, people may confuse the following situations: (1) The shooting was the right thing to do; (2) the shooting was wrong, but the marine followed the rules and therefore did the right thing, and the killed Iraqi is an unfortunate victim of conditions; (3) the shooting was wrong and the marine has to be punished. I think a careful consideration will cleaar this up. I am inclined to see this as (2), but I would postpone any judgement.
Because I think this is an interesting phenomenon. Opinions on both sides seem to be formed without much independent thinking, and still they run strong.
You might also ask me why I mention stayput.org while not adhering to their political agenda. A phenomenon. :-)
Opinions on both sides seem to be formed without much independent thinking, and still they run strong.
It surprises you?
From my particular standpoint, I do not find this petition, or a possible alternative petition to stop killing Iraqis, interesting. They are absolutely predictable, and, at this stage, serve no purpose.
![[personal profile]](https://www.dreamwidth.org/img/silk/identity/user.png){kind=small}
![[identity profile]](https://www.dreamwidth.org/img/silk/identity/openid.png){kind=small}
I did!!!
no subject
no subject
...>>there will be abuse,<<...
shame on you.
no subject
As for this particular case, people may confuse the following situations: (1) The shooting was the right thing to do; (2) the shooting was wrong, but the marine followed the rules and therefore did the right thing, and the killed Iraqi is an unfortunate victim of conditions; (3) the shooting was wrong and the marine has to be punished. I think a careful consideration will cleaar this up. I am inclined to see this as (2), but I would postpone any judgement.
Some typos
Re: Some typos
no subject
no subject
(ps. I, obviously, did not sign it).
no subject
You might also ask me why I mention stayput.org while not adhering to their political agenda. A phenomenon. :-)
Opinions on both sides seem to be formed without much independent thinking
no subject
It surprises you?
From my particular standpoint, I do not find this petition, or a possible alternative petition to stop killing Iraqis, interesting. They are absolutely predictable, and, at this stage, serve no purpose.
no subject